SIGN UP FREE
Survey Templates Surveys Architecture design information for hybrid project

Architecture design information for hybrid project

Architecture design information for hybrid projects


Hybrid projects are projects where new buildings or environments are designed and added to an existing building or environment for the purpose of modifying or enhancing building use and performance.



According to Egan & Latham’s reports on the construction industry, problems such as fragmentation, lack of innovation and life-cycle feedback are some factors that make the industry inefficient. Another crucial factor is information management; acquisition, processing and use. The accuracy of information (graphically or otherwise) utilised during design bears heavily on the successful implementation of a construction project. This is particularly so in hybrid projects because of the unique challenges presented by existing site constraints.



The aim of this survey is to explore the importance of existing building information (or the lack of) on design decision making for hybrid projects. As well as identify the potential impact information deficiency could have on related design and construction activity.



It will take only a few minutes to complete the questionnaire and your responses are confidential. If you have questions at any time about the survey contact us using the email address below.


Thank you very much for your time and support. Please start with the survey now by clicking on the Continue button below.

GENERAL
Based on your firm’s portfolio, please rank the following project types in order of percentage completed in the past 5 years?
>25%
26-50%
51-75%
76-100%
Residential
Commercial(e.g. office, retail)
Industrial (e.g. factory)
Public (e.g. government buildings)
Do you have hybrid projects as part of your firm's project portfolio?
Please rate in percentage how many hybrid projects (compared to other projects) were completed by your firm in the past 5 years?
>25%
26-50%
51-75%
76-100%
Residential
Commercial(e.g. office, retail)
Industrial (e.g. factory)
Public (e.g. government buildings)
Which of the following best represent skills available in your practice? (Select as many as possible)
Who is responsible for liaising with clients/users to acquire information needed for design?
Which of the following stages of the RIBA Plan of work is the design team generally involved with?

INFORMATION REQUIREMENT
Rank the following information sources needed for effective design of hybrid projects. (1 = most important, 10 = least important)
Project brief
Condition survey
Detailed geometric/spatial survey
Spatial analysis
Site, topography survey
Previous drawings
Internal and external photographs
GIS or OS Maps
User feedback
Building regulations/ standards
Other (Please state)
Currently, which of the following information sources do you obtain prior to designing for hybrid projects?
Before
During
After
Outline brief
Condition survey
Detailed geometric/spatial survey
Spatial analysis
Site, topography survey
Previous drawings & details
Internal & external photographs
GIS or OS Maps
User feedback
Building Regulation/Standards
Other (Please state)
Ideally, which of the following information sources would you obtain prior to designing for hybrid projects?
Before
During
After
Outline brief
Condition survey
Detailed geometric/spatial survey
Spatial analysis
Site, topography survey
Previous drawings & details
Internal & external photographs
GIS or OS Maps
User feedback
Building Regulation/Standards
Other (Please state)
Which of the following design criteria is considered while designing hybrid buildings.
never
seldom
often
always
Capacity (level of occupancy)
Quality of internal space
Quality of external environment
Quality of amenity
Adaptability
Functionality
Energy efficiency
Value
Other (Please state)
Which of the following factors influences information acquisition for design?
unimportant
irrelevant
important
highly important
Cost of acquisition
Time taken
Manpower
Skills for acquiring and interpreting data
Other (Please state)
In your opininion, what impact does an existing building have on the following?
Highly Significant
Somewhat Significant
Neutral
Somewhat Insignificant
Insignificant
Type of information and detail required
Time taken to produce design
Design solution or options
Other (Please state)

INFORMATION PROCESSING
Which of the following IT design tools do you use to communicate design concepts of hybrid buildings to clients?
never
seldom
often
always
Sketches
2D drawings
3D models
Physical models
Design simulation
Verbal communication
Other (Please state)
What design decisions are made using the information sources listed below? (Multiple selection possible)
Form
Space
Planning
Functionality
Adaptability
Other
Outline brief
Condition survey
Detailed geometric/spatial survey
Spatial analysis
Site, topography survey
Previous drawings & details
Internal & external photographs
GIS or OS Maps
User feedback
Building Regulation/Standards
Other (Please state)

INFORMATION OUTPUT
Which of the following design output do you produce for hybrid projects?
never
seldom
often
always
2D detailed drawings
Specification
3D virtual models
Simulations
Physical models
Construction phase planning
Other (Please state)
Based on the RIBA Plan of Works, at what stages are these design outputs produced?
(Stage: B = Feasibility, C= Outline proposals, D = Scheme design, E= detailed design, J= Project planning, K= Action on site)
B
C
D
E
J
K
2D detailed drawings
Specification
3D virtual models
Simulations
Physical models
Construction phase planning
Other (Please state)

CONSEQUENCES OF INADEQUATE DESIGN INFORMATION
In your opinion, which of the following is most affected by inadequate information during design and construction of hybrid projects?
highly likely
likely
neutral
unlikely
highly unlikely
Site and associated buildings
Structure
Facade systems
Services
Functional internal spaces
Phased decant and construction planning
Other (Please state)
From your experience of hybrid projects in the past 5 years, which of the following problems arise as a result of inadequate information prior to design?
never
seldom
often
always
Design error
Engineering error
Hindered project planning
Lack of communication
Contractor error
Other (Please state)

CURRENT SOLUTIONS TO LACK OF DESIGN INFORMATION
How will you normally compensate for lack of up-to-date existing building information prior to design? (Please rate frequency and in order of efficiency)
never
seldom
often
always

Effective
Ineffective
Commission detailed traditional survey (text & 2D output)
Commission detailed digital survey (3D output)
Visit site for first hand information (sketches, photos, measurements)
Request information from client/client representative information (text, word-of-mouth)
Deduce information from subjective data (e.g. building type, period etc)
Assume building regulation compliance
Other (Please state)

POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS TO LACK OF DESIGN INFORMATION
Are you aware of or have used any of the following 3D digital technologies?
Yes
No
Dont know
Image-derived 3D models
Terrestrial photogrammetry
Laser Scanning
3D Surveys (Global total station etc)
Mobile mapping systems (MMS)
Other non-conventional techniques (e.g. MRI, CT, RFID)
Other (Please state)
How effective do you think the following technologies will be for resolving lack of hybrid design information in the future?
Dont know
Ineffective
Effective
Highly effective
Image-derived 3D models
Terrestrial photogrammetry
Laser Scanning
3D Surveys (Global total station etc)
Mobile mapping systems (MMS)
Other non-conventional techniques (e.g. MRI, CT, RFID)
Other (Please state)
The following potential advantages of 3D data capture technologies were identified from literature. Are these benefits significant compared to current design practise?
Dont know
Insignificant
Neither
Significant
Highly significant
More accurate design/design decisions
Instant 3D data
Information from a singular source
Time savings
Optimum cost savings
Less manpower requirement
Other (Please state)
How significant are these barriers to utilising 3D data capture technologies such as laser scanning and photogrammetry as part of design activity?
Dont know
Insignificant
Neither
Significant
Highly significant
Non-interoperable data formats
High volume data
Hardware cost
Software cost
High skill requirement
Post-processing time
Other (Please state)
Additional comments

Related templates and questionnaires