BPAMod1 - Customer

BEST PRACTICE ASSESSMENT. MODULE 1: CUSTOMER
0%
 
 
INTRODUCTION

How to complete this Survey.

The Best Practice Assessment is a review of capability within the business against 5 levels of capability, ranging from a Basic Level (Level 1) to a Best Practice Level (Level 5). The Best Practice Assessment covers 4 Modules: 1. Brand Marketing, 2. Innovation, 3. Category and 4. Customer.

You are rating your organisation’s capability in the Customer Module.


Each Module has a series of Components including Strategy, Insights, Process, Measures and People. For each question you are asked to rate your Organisation’s capability against that particular Practice, against the 5 Levels of Capability that are defined.

Please choose the Practice Level that accurately reflects the capability your organisation currently has or operates at.

You are also asked to rate the impact for your Organisation of having Best Practice Capability (Level 5) within the business, for each respective Practice.

Once again, 5 choices are available from Impact Rating 1 - Minimal Impact to Impact Rating 5 - Game Change.

You have the option of adding any comments you feel add context to the ratings you provide on either the Level selected or Impact rating chosen.

Questions 1 & 2 are mandatory, question 3 is optional.

 
 
 
STRATEGY: Direction
 
 
 
* Strategic Business Plan

The extent to which the Strategic Business Plan is communicated to the Customer Teams/National Account Managers in a way that provides direction for strategy and planning development of the Customer Plans.

The strategic Business Plan is the 3-5 year blueprint that defines how the TOTAL BUSINESS UNIT will a) Become more profitable (b) Improve its competitive position (c) Efficiently distribute/utilise the shareholder value created. Typically it would include a small number of strategies that remain reasonably consistent over time.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 The Strategic Business Plan is not communicated through the business.
 
L2 Parts of Strategic Business Plan are communicated but usually ad-hoc and/or after Customer Plans are prepared and this information usually provides little direction for customer activity.
 
L3 The Strategic Business Plan is usually communicated after the Customer Plans are prepared but provides some direction for customer activity.
 
L4 The Strategic Business Plan is communicated prior to the Customer Plans being prepared and provides some direction for customer strategic planning.
 
L5 The Strategic Business Plan is communicated prior to the Customer Plans being prepared and provides clear direction for customer strategic planning. The strategic business plan clearly shows up and is linked in all customer plans
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Input and Involvement forming a major part of what the plan looks like


Measures the degree and quality of customer input into business strategy development. This is formally reviewed, discussed, aligned upon and fed into the strategic planning process with clear strategic customer initiatives associated to it

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 The strategic business plan is developed with little or no customer strategy information incorporated.
 
L2 The strategic plan development has an ad-hoc approach to feeding customer thinking into the strategic planning process. This is usually a conversation with the sales director or senior commercial people.
 
L3 The strategic plan development has some customer strategy information incorporated into the plan and this is fed through a clear process.
 
L4 The strategic plan development has a good degree of customer strategy information and input incorporated into the plan. This is formally captured and communicated for input into the plan development.
 
L5 The strategic business plan is development incorporates key customer input before the plan is started. Key customer strategy information is formally reviewed and incorporated at the beginning of the process and is instrumental in the plan development.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Long Term Planning/Strategies


The extent to which the account team builds plans with a focus on the long term as well as the short term, day-to-day issues. Short term activities comply with the longer term plans .

Long Term = beyond the current year, ideally 3 years out

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.


KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our Account team only operates in the short term.
 
L2 Our Account team writes Customer Plans that encompass both Long term and Short Term goals and account managers often compromise long term goals.
 
L3 Our Account team writes Customer Plans that encompass both Long term and Short Term goals and account managers occasionally compromise long term goals for highly important short term issues.
 
L4 Our Account team writes Customer Plans that encompass both Long term and Short Term goals and in-market activities inconsistent with the long term need Director level approval.
 
L5 Our Account team writes Customer Plans that encompass both Long term and Short Term goals and all in-market activities are managed in the context of the long term.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Alignment of Business Plans


The extent to which your Business, Marketing, Sales, Category, Customer and Brand plans are developed as one strategic process and are fully integrated with each other so that all functions are working to achieve the same goals and are aligned to the same strategies.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our business plans are developed separately and we try and link them afterwards.
 
L2 Our business plans are developed in separate functional processes with some limited consideration of each other.
 
L3 Our business plans are developed in separate functional processes and teams but with extensive cross-functional communication.
 
L4 Our business plans are developed in the same strategic process but with separate functional teams and extensive cross-functional communication.
 
L5 Our business plans are developed within the same strategic process with cross-functional engagement and are aligned and integrated.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Channel Strategy


The extent to which you have a Channel Strategy which defines the channel’s role and priority by category and defines strategic and tactical guidelines and specific initiatives for each key channel.

How you intend to service each channel, the resources allocated to and the anticipated return from each channel. It also defines its total anticipated impact on future earnings.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not have formal channel strategy.
 
L2 We have an implicitly understood channel strategy that provides some direction and outlines some tactical differences by channel. We have a basic understanding on profitability by channel and customers.
 
L3 We have an explicit channel strategy that provides some direction and defines (mainly) tactical guidelines by channel. We have some understanding on profitability by channel and customers.
 
L4 We have an explicit channel strategy that provides some direction and defines our choice of major initiatives and tactical guidelines by channel. We have real clarity on profitability by channel and customers.
 
L5 We have a comprehensive channel strategy that provides clear direction and stipulates major initiatives and tactical guidelines by channel. We have real clarity on profitability by channel and customer and any investment decision is made based on where the most value is available.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Long Term Category Strategies


The degree to which you develop Category Strategies for how you intend to create performance improvement for your key customers.

A category strategy is a defined area of focus that seeks to change consumer and/or shopper behaviour to achieve a defined performance improvement goal for the category as a whole. Strategy determines how resources are directed.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not formally develop long term category strategies.
 
L2 We have a 1 - 3 year strategic plan for category improvement but is not formally communicated or widely understood.
 
L3 We have a 1 - 3 year strategic plan for category improvement that is understood by most of our sales and marketing people and has been communicated to most customers.
 
L4 We have a 3 year strategic plan for category improvement which substantially drives our own business plans. It has been communicated to most customers.
 
L5 We have a 3 year strategic plan for category improvement which substantially drives our own business plans. It has been developed in collaboration with key customers and we aim to implement jointly.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Management Strategy

The degree to which you develop a business unit customer management strategy to define the key priorities and choices or resource application to maximize your sales effectiveness

A customer management strategy identifies the key performance improvement opportunities in its customer interface and selects a small number of high priority strategies to direct resources where maximum benefit can be gained.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not formally develop long term customer management strategy.
 
L2 We have a 1 - 3 year strategic plan for customer management but it is not formally communicated or widely understood.
 
L3 We have a 1 - 3 year customer management plan that is understood by most of our sales management by only loosely drives our activities.
 
L4 We have a 3 year strategic plan for customer management which substantially drives our activities. It has been communicated to the sales management team.
 
L5 We have a 3 year strategic plan for customer management which substantially drives our activities. It has been developed in cross-functional collaboration and is supported by the Executive team and communicated across the business.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Plans – Collaboration

To what extent are your individual customer plans developed and resourced in collaboration with the customer and multiple functions inside your company resulting in agreed multi-functional Customer Plans.

A cross-functional plan encompasses both demand and supply side strategies into a single plan

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 The direction of our customer plans are controlled largely by the customer and we do not work cross-functionally around one plan.
 
L2 Customer Plans are developed by the supplier, taking note of the customer agenda, and presented to the customer by the supplier. Resources are not aligned.
 
L3 Customer Plans are developed in collaboration between the account manager and the buyer who engage other internal functions where necessary. Cross-functional resources are not clearly aligned. We negotiate through this during the year.
 
L4 Total collaboration both customer and supplier include multiple functions in developing and agreeing Customer Plans and resources allocated partially by both customer and supplier against the plan priorities.
 
L5 Total collaboration both customer and supplier include multiple functions in developing and agreeing Customer Plans so resources are aligned against the multi-functional plan priorities.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Strategy/Tactics Linkage


The extent to which your strategies drive all planning and tactical activities.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our entire tactical focus is on delivering short term volume results.
 
L2 We have strategies but only sometimes use them to select and prioritise our tactical activity – focus is usually about achieving short term volume results.
 
L3 We use our strategies to select and prioritise our tactical activity – most of our plans are created to fulfill these strategies however the agenda regularly shifts to short term volume requirements and we often struggle to get back to our planned tactics.
 
L4 We use our strategies to select and prioritise our tactical activity – most of our plans are created to fulfill these strategies and when short term considerations change the agenda we rapidly get back to our planned tactics.
 
L5 We use our strategies to select and prioritise our tactical activity – almost all of our plans are created to fulfill these strategies rather than simply to fulfill short term volume requirements, we rarely are diverted from these.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Competitor Strategies


Our Customer Planning process explicitly articulates our knowledge of major competitor’s strategies, their anticipated actions in fulfilling them and our contingency reactions to them.

For example anticipating significant ranging pricing and merchandising proposals

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our Customer plans do not cover the competitive environment.
 
L2 Our Customer Plans do make general assumptions about the competitive environment but we rely on our ability to react to counter those initiatives.
 
L3 Our Customer Plans make general assumptions about the competitive environment and contain prepared reactions to some general competitor initiatives (e.g. price increase).
 
L4 Our Customer Plans predict major competitor’s strategies and tactics and do contain some prepared reactions to some general competitor initiatives.
 
L5 Our Customer Plans predict major competitor’s strategies and tactics and contain a detailed set of pre-emptive and reactive initiatives to ensure we stay ahead of competition
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
STRATEGY: Prioritisation
 
 
 
* Customer Segmentation Strategy


The extent to which you have a clear segmentation model of your channels and customers based on robust research and customer feedback, that drives your resource allocation.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not have a channel/customer based segmentation.
 
L2 We have a customer segmentation model that has been derived from internal judgment only.
 
L3 We have a customer segmentation model that has been derived from internal judgment as well as feedback from customers.
 
L4 We have a customer segmentation model that has been derived from a qualitative objective external research in one main channel only as well as feedback from customers.
 
L5 We have a customer segmentation model that has been derived from quantitative and qualitative objective external research across multiple channels as well as feedback from customers.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Segmentation Application

The extent to which your Customer Segmentation model is applied when developing sales strategies and tactics across and between channels and your customer base

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 … we do not have a customer segmentation model.
 
L2 … informally considered when developing sales strategies but is not often applied with any consistency.
 
L3 … formally considered when developing sales strategies but is regularly overruled by tactical considerations.
 
L4 … formally considered when developing sales strategies which are sometimes adjusted to fit the model.
 
L5 … a major input in development of all our sales strategies so that everything we do is influenced by the model.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Investment by Strategic Imperative

The extent to which your business sets explicit trade investment budgets by specific strategy.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We allocate trade investment budgets based only on account investment history.
 
L2 We allocate trade investment based on changes in the account plans to support this year’s initiatives, not just on history.
 
L3 Some components of trade investment are allocated to strategic imperatives but we do not formally monitor implementation.
 
L4 We have a process for allocating trade investment budgets by strategic imperative for some key customers and we sometimes monitor implementation for effectiveness. We have clear initiatives defined to reduce or drive efficiency in trade spend.
 
L5 We allocate trade investment budgets by strategic imperative for each of our key customers and we continually monitor implementation to ensure effectiveness. We have clear initiatives defined to reduce or drive efficiency in trade spend. Measured quarterly.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Resource Review

The extent to which priorities are regularly reviewed with resource requirements taken into account and bottlenecks reviewed with outcomes implemented.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not review resource priorities or bottlenecks.
 
L2 We have regular reviews of priorities and resources but these are rarely implemented.
 
L3 We have occasional reviews that sometimes result in outcomes that are sometimes implemented.
 
L4 We have regular reviews of priorities and resources that result in outcomes that are sometimes implemented.
 
L5 We have regular reviews of priorities and resources that result in specific outcomes that are consistently implemented.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Activity Guidelines

The extent to which your business has strategic policies and/or guidelines around channel and customer activity (e.g. price and promotions) in place to give your Account Managers autonomy in decision making while helping to minimise commercial conflicts.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We have no guidelines.
 
L2 We have rough guidelines that are not well understood nor adhered to by all Account Managers.
 
L3 We have some guidelines that are understood but not always adhered to by all Account Managers.
 
L4 We have clear and agreed guidelines that are understood and adhered to by all Account Managers.
 
L5 We have formal co-developed policies that are understood and adhered to by all Account Managers.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
STRATEGY: Leadership
 
 
 
* Executive Management Support

The extent to which the Executive Team are passionate advocates of our Customer, both internally and externally. This is demonstrated by active involvement and support of Customer Plan content, approval and execution.

CEO/Managing Director’s Direct Reports

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our customer plans do not receive significant support at Executive Team level.
 
L2 We prepare detailed written customer plans annually that are reviewed, contributed to and agreed by the Sales or Category Directors and only they actively remove obstacles and/or facilitate the execution of planned activities.
 
L3 We prepare detailed written customer plans annually that are reviewed, contributed to and agreed by the Business Unit Executive Team but only our Sales Director actively remove obstacles and/or facilitate the execution of planned activities.
 
L4 We prepare detailed written customer plans annually that are reviewed, contributed to and agreed by the Business Unit Executive Team and Sales, Category and Marketing Directors actively remove obstacles and/or facilitate the execution of planned activities.
 
L5 We prepare detailed written customer plans annually that are reviewed, contributed to and agreed by the Business Unit Executive Team and all Executive Team members actively remove obstacles and/or facilitate the execution of planned activities.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Conflict Resolution

The speed at which actual or potential conflicts with your key customers are resolved and the extent to which your senior management are involved in the dispute resolution.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Senior management are not very proactive or responsive in considering potential conflicts with our key customers.
 
L2 Senior management do not specifically meet with Account Managers to review potential conflicts. When conflicts arise response to the customer can be a little slow.
 
L3 Senior management do not specifically meet with Account Managers but will try to minimise the onset of conflicts if they are made aware of them and will respond as soon as they are able to should a conflict arise.
 
L4 Senior management have informal meetings with Account Managers to review potential conflicts and will respond as soon as they are able to should a conflict arise.
 
L5 Senior management have regular planned meetings with Account Managers in which potential conflicts are raised as agenda items and responded as a priority should a conflict arise. This is supported by formal conflict resolution guidelines to speed dispute resolution amongst teams.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Top to Top Alignment

The extent to which your senior cross-functional management regularly meet with each of your key customers to agree firm category objectives and strategies.

“Top to Top” refers to the joint direction of mutually beneficial strategies by the senior executives on both sides working together

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 There is little regular interaction by senior management with customers on strategy issues.
 
L2 Our Senior Sales teams regularly meet their counterparts in our major customers however we often do not have category strategies agreed through this process.
 
L3 Our Executive Sales teams regularly meet their counterparts in our major customers and our business plans form some part of dialogue but normally without creating firm commitments.
 
L4 Our CEO/GM, Executive Sales and Marketing team regularly meet their counterparts in our major customers and our category strategies form a core part of the dialogue and we usually agree firm commitments.
 
L5 Our CEO/GM, Executive Sales, Marketing and Supply Chain management team regularly meet their counterparts in our major customers and reach agreed category strategies with defined goals as a core part of an ongoing agreement and review process.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
STRATEGY SUMMARY

Direction
Strategic business plan
Long term planning/strategies
Alignment of business plans
Channel strategy
Long term category strategies
Customer management strategy
Customer plans - collaboration
Strategy/tactics linkage
Competitor strategies

Prioritisation
Customer segmentation strategy
Customer segmentation application
Investment by strategic imperatives
Resource review
Activity guidelines

Leadership
Executive management support
Conflict resolution
Top to top alignment
 
 
 
LEARNINGS: STRATEGY
 
 
 
Sources of Advantage
   
 
 
 
Improvement Opportunities
   
 
 
 
INSIGHT: Consumer
 
 
 
* Application of Consumer Insight into Customer Plans


The extent to which you are able to bring the consumer knowledge your business has to develop more effective plans with your key customers.

Consumer Knowledge = objective, broad research learnings with identified application to consumption growth opportunities with our categories (e.g. new consumer, new consumption occasions).

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We rarely leverage consumer research investment outside our internal brand initiative decisions.
 
L2 We share consumer research when we present our new initiatives as part of the justification but there is rarely any wider application of insight.
 
L3 Some individuals occasionally take new consumer insights to our customers but they are not really integrated into our plans.
 
L4 Our customer facing teams regularly receive briefings on new consumer insights and adopt them into account plans where there is a specific reason to do so.
 
L5 Our customer facing teams input into and fully engage with a range of consumer insight initiatives and continually maintain a dialogue with our customers on evolving consumer needs in our categories.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
INSIGHT: Shopper
 
 
 
* Use of Scan Sales Data


The extent to which your account teams engage with the customer in reporting market place trends and opportunities in Scan Sales Data

Scan sales is the aggregation of individual account scanning sales to give a complete picture of market sales, split by category, segment and brand.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not use scan sales data with key accounts on any frequent basis.
 
L2 A few of our customer facing people (sales or category) prepare presentations on scan sales information for others to use but we do not do this on a frequent basis.
 
L3 Some of our customer facing people (sales or category) access scan data and create reports for customer meetings on a regular basis but we are not seen as a key advisor.
 
L4 We are seen as a key advisor by our main customers on scan sales trends and all our customer facing people access and use data but only some create their own tailor-made reporting for customers on a regular basis.
 
L5 We are seen as a key advisor by our main customers on scan sales trends and all of our customer facing people access and use this data and almost all create their own tailor-made reporting for customers on a regular basis.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Shopper Insights Driving Strategy


The extent that shopper insights is driving strategy in promotional planning, merchandising strategy, slotting board broken down by key trading periods during the year

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not use shopper insights in our strategy and initiative development that we implement with customers.
 
L2 Shopper insights are used in a few areas of our strategy and initiative development that we implement. It comes through occasionally.
 
L3 Shopper insights are used in some of our strategy and initiative development that we implement.
 
L4 We use shopper insights in a most of our strategy and initiative development. It is one of key sources of information that we use to formulate our plans in nearly all our customer execution plans.
 
L5 Shopper insights is inextricably linked to all strategy development that is customer facing and used to develop customer initiatives and plans. This is very clearly specified in all strategy briefings.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Use of Household Panel Sales Data


The extent to which your account teams engage with customer in reporting market place trends and opportunities in shopper purchasing

Household panels gather purchasing data from a large number of homes to show changes in choices in stores and behaviour change over time in purchasing dynamics.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not use household panel data with key accounts on any frequent basis.
 
L2 A few of our customer team personnel (sales and category) prepare presentations on purchase behaviour information for others to use but we do not do this on a frequent basis.
 
L3 Some of our customer team personnel (sales and category) access purchase behaviour and create reports for customer meetings on a regular basis but we are not seen as a key advisor.
 
L4 We are seen as a key advisor by our main customers on purchase behaviour trends and all our of our customer team personnel access and use data but only some create their own tailor-made reporting for customers on a regular basis.
 
L5 We are seen as a key advisor by our main customers on purchase behaviour trends and all our of our customer team personnel access and use this data and almost all create their own tailor-made reporting for customers on a regular basis.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Use of Retailer Basket or Card Sales Data


The extent to which your account teams engage with customer in analysing trends and opportunities in retailer data

Retailer basket or card data provides the individual purchase patterns by shopper on each shopping occasion. Card data adds to this information about the purchaser.


Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not use retail shopper data with key accounts on any frequent basis.
 
L2 A few of our customer team personnel (sales and category) prepare presentations on retailer shopper data for others to use but we do not do this on a frequent basis.
 
L3 Some of our customer team personnel (sales and category) access retailer shopper data and create reports for customer meetings on a regular basis but we are not seen as a key advisor.
 
L4 We are seen as a key advisor by our main customers on retailer shopper data and all our of our customer team personnel access and use data but only some create their own tailor-made reporting for customers on a regular basis.
 
L5 We are seen as a key advisor by our main customers on retailer shopper data and all our of our customer team personnel access and use this data and almost all create their own tailor-made reporting for customers on a regular basis.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Application of Shopper Insight into Customer Plans


The extent to which you are able to use shopper knowledge to develop more effective plans with your key customers

Shopper Knowledge = objective broad research learnings with identified application to category growth opportunities at point of purchase within our categories (e.g. trade up, new shoppers, increased weight of purchase, cross-purchasing, increased penetration/frequency).

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We rarely leverage shopper research investment.
 
L2 We share shopper research when we present our new initiatives as part of the justification but there is rarely any wider application of insight.
 
L3 Some individuals occasionally take new shopper insights to our customers but they are not really integrated into our plans.
 
L4 Our customer facing teams regularly receive briefings on new shopper insights and adopt them into account plans where there is a specific reason to do so.
 
L5 Our customer facing teams input and fully engage with a range of shopper insight initiatives and continually maintain a dialogue with our customers on evolving shopper needs in our categories.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
INSIGHTS: Specialist
 
 
 
* Customer Understanding

The extent to which you comprehensively know your customers and record this knowledge for use by others in the business

A comprehensive knowledge of your customer includes an understanding of their business and trading strategies, their competitive strengths and weaknesses, their people in terms of who holds which position and any personal preferences or agencies they have as well as the locations of stores, distribution centres and their processes and systems.


Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not stipulate what we should understand about key customers.
 
L2 We have a broad understanding of our key customers and record some stipulated relevant information that is shared with colleagues on request.
 
L3 We have a comprehensive understanding of our key customers and recording varies by individual and is generally shared on request.
 
L4 We have a comprehensive understanding of our key customers and record some stipulated relevant information that is shared with colleagues on request.
 
L5 We have a comprehensive understanding of our key customers and systematically record all relevant information that enables access by authorised colleagues.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Ideas and Information Exchange

The extent to which you exchange ideas and information with your key customers in a comprehensive fashion e.g. sharing trends, data, research (economic, industry, category etc.)

An initiative is a significant plan or project chosen to deliver a strategic goal.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 No exchange of information takes place.
 
L2 An exchange forum is ad hoc and attended as necessary on exchanges of information and ideas with our key customers.
 
L3 A formal exchange forum is established and attended on a six monthly basis on exchanges of information and ideas with our key customers.
 
L4 A formal exchange forum is established and attended on a quarterly basis in line with customer/business reviews on exchanges of information and ideas with our key customers.
 
L5 A formal exchange forum is established and attended on a monthly basis on exchanges of information and ideas with our key customers.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Needs Integration

The extent to which your planning process takes into account the needs of your customers developed in discussion with them

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not consider the specific needs and strategies of our key customers as part of our planning process, the account managers adapt the plan once developed.
 
L2 Our customer plans include some formal consideration of the needs and strategies of our key customers but these are generally inferred – taken from our own judgement on what is important to the customer.
 
L3 Integrating customer needs and strategies into our planning process comes in at the customer plan stage and considers the needs of our key customers as provided by them.
 
L4 Integrating customer needs and strategies into our planning process is part of the strategic business planning process and considers the needs of our key customers developed in discussion with them.
 
L5 Integrating customer needs and strategies into our Total Company planning process is part of the strategic business planning process and builds in the needs of our key customers as developed in discussion with them.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Initiative Testing


The extent to which you collaborate with your key customers in regards to research to validate initiatives prior to launch and the extent to which this initiative testing serves as a key driver to investment decisions.

An initiative is a significant plan or project chosen to deliver a strategic goal.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not Undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We usually implement initiatives without prior testing.
 
L2 Our most significant category initiatives have some form of prior validation using internal evaluation processes.
 
L3 We normally use external pre-testing research to evaluate key initiatives prior to launch.
 
L4 We collaborate with customers in joint research protocols for major initiatives before deciding on investment decisions.
 
L5 We collaborate with customers in joint research protocols for major initiatives before deciding on investment decisions, usually including major scale in-store trials, planned with our customers, tracking results to make a joint decision on roll out.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
INSIGHT SUMMARY

Consumer
Application of consumer insight into customer plans

Shopper
Use of scan sales data
Use of household panel sales data
Use of retailer basket or card sales data
Application of shopper insight into customer plans

Specialist
Customer understanding
Ideas and information exchange
Customer needs integration
Initiative testing
 
 
 
LEARNINGS: INSIGHT
 
 
 
Sources of Advantage
   
 
 
 
Improvement Opportunities
   
 
 
 
PROCESS: Planning
 
 
 
* Account Planning


The extent to which the account team prepare a robust and thorough plan for the account that aligns and guides activity for the year.


An account plan should encompass a situation analysis to identify performance opportunities, clear objectives, big picture strategies to guide priorities and detailed plans for all aspects of the account, as well as the numbers

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not operate formal account plans.
 
L2 Account managers prepare an account plan but focus is on the ‘numbers’ only with minimal management or cross functional input.
 
L3 We prepare formal account plans but the content is limited and variable and sign off is within the sales function only.
 
L4 We prepare a detailed and robust account plan for each key account that forms the basis of all activity planning for that year, but is not widely considered outside of the sales function.
 
L5 We prepare a detailed and robust account plan for each key account that is signed off by senior sales, category and marketing executives and forms the basis of all activity planning for that year.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Resource Allocation


The extent to which customer plans are allocated sufficient resources to achieve their objectives and strategies. Also, they demonstrate a clear rationale for the resources allocated to each specific activity in the plan.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.


KEY: L1 Not under taken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Customer Plans do not exist or are not allocated sufficient resources or allocate resources by general activity area.
 
L2 Customer Plans are allocated insufficient resources to achieve their objectives and allocate resources justified by general activity.
 
L3 Customer Plans are allocated insufficient resources to achieve their objectives but allocate resources justified by general activity.
 
L4 Customer Plans are allocated sufficient resources to achieve their objectives and allocate resources justified by general activity area.
 
L5 customer Plans are allocated sufficient resources to achieve their objectives and allocate resources justified by specific activity area.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Validation of Robust Customer Strategies


The extent to which account strategies are validated via cost benefit and are insight driven

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We rarely expect justification of account strategies.
 
L2 Account strategies require some kind of business case but the content and evaluation of these is highly variable.
 
L3 One of the most significant investment strategies require cost benefit analysis and most account plans are not based on shopper insights.
 
L4 Agreed account strategies require justification in terms of cost benefit and are expected to have clear linkage to performance improvement but not necessarily based on shopper insight.
 
L5 Agreed account strategies require justification in terms of cost benefit and must demonstrate a basis in an understanding how to improve performance through meeting the customer’s needs more effectively.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Situation Analysis


Identifying and agreeing key opportunities in each key customer through a broad situation analysis of market and category performance data to improve sales, share, profit and consumer satisfaction

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We rarely spend much time assessing category opportunities from data for our categories.
 
L2 We sometimes carry out an assessment of category data when the needs arises to present to our customers but select the ‘stories’ that are most useful to support of our marketing plans.
 
L3 We conduct an annual assessment of opportunities using some data but do not distil them into a shortlist of significant opportunities.
 
L4 We conduct an annual assessment of opportunities using a wide breadth of data then distil them into significant opportunities which we share with our customers to agree and select opportunities to develop.
 
L5 We conduct a regular assessment of opportunities – asking questions and collecting a wide breadth of data to validate and quantify and then collaborate with our customers to agree and select opportunities to develop. We continually review to identify necessary corrections/changes early.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Category Management Process


The extent to which you have an agreed approach to category management based on consumer and shopper needs which considers all of the important category management process elements


Category management should include category definition and segmentation, role, situation assessment, scorecard agreement, strategies, initiatives, implementation tracking (and regular reviews).

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not use a category planning process.
 
L2 We use an informal category planning process that is not well defined and used ad-hoc.
 
L3 We sometimes use formalised category management processes that considers some aspects of the category management process.
 
L4 We consistently use a formalised category management approach that considers all key aspects of the category management process. The process relies on panel and scan data which is current, detailed and drives our strategies.
 
L5 We consistently use a formalised consumer and shopper centric category management approach that considers all key aspects of the category management process. The process relies heavily on a mix of consumer, shopper, panel and scan data which is current, detailed and drives our strategies.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Category Strategy Business Alignment


The extent to which we have developed a category strategy that drives the alignment of brands, customer, shopper and consumer across the entire organisation

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 While it exists our category strategy does not align the business cross-functionally on common goals and objectives.
 
L2 In some areas our category strategy brings together a customer, shopper and consumer and aligns the business behind driving common goals and objectives across the organisation.
 
L3 Occasionally out category strategy brings together customer, shopper and consumer and aligns the business behind driving common goals and objectives across the organisation.
 
L4 On most occasions our category strategy brings together customer, shopper and consumer and strategically aligns the business behind writing common goals and objectives across the total organisation.
 
L5 Consistently our category strategy brings together customer, shopper and consumer and strategically aligns the business behind writing common goals and objectives across the total organisation.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Strategic Management of Pricing


The extent to which your business manages shelf and promotional pricing (frequency and depth) to ensure optimal category value creation

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We develop pricing based only on short term market pricing history.
 
L2 We have subjective understanding of the management of pricing and this sometimes influences market pricing decisions.
 
L3 We have some objective understanding of the management of pricing and our pricing strategy is understood by our customers and sometimes influences market pricing decisions.
 
L4 We have a quantitative model for managing pricing (frequency and depth) and our pricing strategy is understood by our customers and sometimes drives in-market pricing.
 
L5 We have a robust quantitative predictive model for managing pricing by SKU (frequency and depth) and our pricing strategy is understood by our customers and consistently drives in-market pricing.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Price Value Creation through Shopper Insights


To the extent which we have developed a promotional strategy using an in depth understanding of the shopper’s reliance on price as a core lever of the shopping mission

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Shopper mission insights is not really considered as a core input to our promotional strategy and trade spend targeted investment.
 
L2 Sometimes we use shopper mission insights to understand shopper pricing sensitivity and use these to drive out promotional strategy and to target scan and trade spend to areas where value creation is evident.
 
L3 Occasionally we use shopper mission insights to understand shopper pricing sensitivity and use these to drive our promotional strategy and to target scan and trade spend to areas where value creation is evident.
 
L4 On most occasions we use shopper mission insights to understand shopper pricing sensitivity and use these to drive our promotional strategy and to target scan and trade spend to areas where value creation is evident.
 
L5 We consistently use shopper mission insights to understand shopper pricing sensitivity and use these to drive our promotional strategy and to target scan and trade spend to areas where value creation is evident.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Sales Forecasting Process


The process for sales forecasting is formal with regular meetings of multiple options including customer input that reduce an agreed forecast to which the whole business works without adjustment

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Forecasting planners are responsible for developing forecasts based on history and system generated forecasts with no other inputs from sales or marketing.
 
L2 Sales forecasting is dominated by one or two function’s inputs and agreement. They are integrated into Sales and Operational Planning AFTER adjustment creating multiple forecasts within the business creating confusion and rework.
 
L3 Sales forecasting is dominated by one or two function’s inputs and agreement. They are automatically integrated into Sales and Operational Planning unadjusted creating the single set of forecasts to which the business works.
 
L4 Sales forecasting is a multi-functional formal process with Customer, Sales, Marketing and operations in courts and agreement. They are integrated into sales and Operational Planning AFTER adjustment creating multiple forecasts within the business.
 
L5 Sales forecasting is a multi-functional formal process with Customer, Sales, Marketing and Operations inputs and agreement. They are automatically integrated into Sales and Operational Planning unadjusted creating the single set of forecasts to which the business works.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
PROCESS: Execution
 
 
 
* Promotional Planning – Financial Investment


The extent to which your promotional investment is decided using rigourous and objective financial assessment of the ROI of past activity

ROI is return on investment, the net profit resulting from the promotion.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not undertake any significant or widespread ROI analysis.
 
L2 Some major promotions are subject to post event ROI analysis but the learning from this is not well documented or understood.
 
L3 We establish outline promotional guidance using some historic ROI analysis applied by brand/product setting the limits of promotions but not detail beyond this.
 
L4 We have a detailed assessment of historic ROI on key promotions on leading brands which is applied using clear rules/guidelines but limited to our own business and requirements.
 
L5 Promotions are planned and executed within firm quantitative price/discount guidelines by product/brand developed by specialists based on our historic ROI analysis to ensure optimised future return on investment. We broaden our analysis to be able to offer category-wide advice to customers.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Promotional Planning – Internal Controls


The extent to which promotion investment is controlled by cross-functional senior management

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not have formally applied senior management controls on promotional spend.
 
L2 There are implicitly understood requirements as to how and when promotional plans require sales management sign off before execution.
 
L3 We have explicit rules determining how and when promotions need sign off and agreement by senior sales management that are inconsistently applied.
 
L4 We have explicit rules determining how and when promotions need sign off and agreement by senior cross-functional management (including sales, marketing, finance and Supply chain) and are consistently applied.
 
L5 We have explicit rules determining how and when promotions need sign off and agreement by senior cross-functional management which are consistently applied, reviewed by a regular cross-functional forum.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Promotional Planning – Tailoring


The extent to which promotional strategy is developed to align with customer specific business needs/opportunities

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We offer the same promotional deals to all our key customers.
 
L2 We seek to offer minor differences (executional differences) to customers to avoid in-market conflict/clashes.
 
L3 We provide a menu of promotions options and allow account managers with customers to select different choices.
 
L4 We have a strategy to align our promotional investments directly with explicitly developed customer specific opportunities.
 
L5 We consistently invest our marketing funds collaboratively in developing unique ‘win win’ co-marketing activities for key customers based on an objective assessment of the business opportunities.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Promotional Planning – Reviews


The extent to which there is a regular cross-functional review of promotional outcomes against plans and pre-promotion ROI analysis. Differences are understood, learnings adopted and captured for future planning purposes. Non-adherence to guidelines and controls are identified.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not have any formal reviews of promotional results.
 
L2 We have ad-hoc reviews of promotional results within the sales/category functions but without documentation of learnings.
 
L3 We have regular formal reviews of promotional results in the sales/category function and document learnings.
 
L4 We have regular cross-functional reviews of promotional results but do not document learnings or outcomes.
 
L5 We have regular cross-functional reviews where learnings are well documented and non-adherence identified and dealt with.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Innovation Pipeline

The extent to which we formally integrate key customers’ input to our innovation process and work towards a “win-win” in product development

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We rarely invite customer feedback/nput into our innovation pipeline
 
L2 Our key customers are sometimes informally invited to contribute ideas into our innovation pipeline
 
L3 Our key customers are regularly invited as part of a formal process to contribute ideas and provide feedback on the early stages of our new product concept development
 
L4 Our key customers are regularly invited as part of a formal process to contribute ideas and provide feedback on the early stages of our concept development and we actively prioritise ideas that have a high potential for “win-win” with our customers
 
L5 Customers work with us on the idea generation process and share “ownership” of ideas as a result. We actively prioritise ideas that have a high potential for “win-win” with our customers and seek out ways to tailor opportunities by key customer
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Promotion and NPD Forecasting

The extent to which you forecast for special events such as promotions and new product launches and the degree to which collaborative input from your key customers is enlisted in this process

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We rarely prepare internal forecasts for significant special events such as new launches or big promotions
 
L2 We sometimes prepare an internal forecast for significant special events such as new launches or big promotions
 
L3 We always prepare an internal forecast for significant special events such as new launches or big promotion
 
L4 WE sometimes agree a joint forecast with customers for significant special events such as new launches or big promotions
 
L5 We always agree a joint forecast with customers for significant special events such as new launches or big promotions
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Joint Implementation Planning

The extent to which you collaborate with your key customers in the planning and implementation of initiatives

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We normally simply advise customers of our impending plans within their minimum time limits
 
L2 We have an annual plan with our customers with some of our key initiatives timetabled in advance to allow for some discussion early in the process, but most initiatives are simply advised to customers on the standard time frame
 
L3 Our sales team plan initiatives in broad terms in the annual plan at a buyer level and then in detail several months ahead of the minimum to discuss how best to implement
 
L4 Our sales team raise our planned initiatives in broad terms at least quarterly at both senior and buyer level and then in detail several months ahead of the minimum to discuss how best to implement
 
L5 Our cross functional people normally collaborate directly with customers’ team members in frequent planning meetings throughout the year to manage project implementation
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Tailored Customer Marketing Activity

The extent to which you tailor marketing activities to each of your key customers to suit their specific requirements and promote differentiation between accounts

Marketing activities might include specific point of sale/merchandising initiatives, advertising or promotional themes

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not adjust activity by customer or channel to any great extent
 
L2 We have occasionally adjusted marketing activity to provide customer activity differentiation on an ad hoc basis
 
L3 We have a broad tailored marketing activity plan at a customer level, and our strategy is understood by our customers and we sometimes adjust market activity accordingly
 
L4 We have a detailed tailored marketing activity plan which takes into account customer strategies and is managed to assist channel and customer differentiation. The strategy is understood by our customers and sometimes drives in market activity with ad hoc ROI achieved.
 
L5 We have a detailed tailored marketing activity plan which takes into account customer strategies and is managed to assist channel and customer differentiation. The strategy is understood by our customers and consistently drives in market activity that achieves a measured and agreed internal ROI
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Brand POP Orientation


The extent to which your brand plans are oriented towards superior point of purchase execution.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Point of purchase thinking is not part of our normal marketing agenda.
 
L2 Point of purchase thinking is added to our brand plans but often as a last minute adjustment or addition.
 
L3 We develop point of purchase strategy within our marketing plans that but the content is limited and our marketing team spends minimal time on this relying on the Sales function to take and adapt their activity.
 
L4 Sales input into marketing plans is sought early so that each major initiative has an agreed point of purchase element, this is a key plank of our marketing strategy.
 
L5 Brand activity is developed with an integrated mindset with point of purchase and shopper engagement a driving consideration from day one. Sales input is sought in advance around marketing initiatives to build our plans to maximise effectiveness at point of purchase.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
PROCESS: Enablers
 
 
 
* Customer Performance Reporting


The extent to which the business has a customer performance reporting suite that enables review of financial and Supply chain performance and proactively highlights issues

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not review customer business performance in terms of Supply and Demand on a daily basis.
 
L2 Our customer business reporting suite incorporates tracking of only financial metrics but Supply and Demand issues are highlighted by people.
 
L3 Our customer business reporting suite incorporates tracking of both financial and Supply chain metrics but Supply and Demand issues are highlighted by people.
 
L4 Our customer business reporting suite incorporates tracking of only financial metrics and proactively highlights Demand and/or Supply issues.
 
L5 Our customer business reporting suite incorporates tracking of both financial and Supply chain metrics and proactively highlights Demand and Supply issues.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Market Performance Monitoring Tools


We have software and/or analysts that silicate issues raised analysis of continuous data (e.g. retails scan, consumer panel or customer financials). Regularly receive the answer is reported in pre-prepared analyses formats

e.g. Price relative to category average and branding share rather than just the price level.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not have any specialist analysis infrastructure or regular reporting of data.
 
L2 We have limited analysis infrastructure meaning Marketing spend much time retrieving data to complete their own fact based issue analysis, but we report monthly continuous data as data rather than information.
 
L3 We have limited analysis infrastructure meaning Marketing spend much time retrieving data to complete the owner fact-based issue analysis. We report monthly continuous data as a suite of predetermined informative analyses rather than raw data.
 
L4 We have purpose allocated analysis resources (people and/or IT tools) that facilitate fact-based issue analysis but we report monthly continuous data as data rather than information.
 
L5 We have purpose allocated analysis resources (people and/or IT tools) we also report monthly continuous data as a suite of informative analyses rather than raw data.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Knowledge Library


Our business captures and records all current (reliable) customer insight in a library which is accessible and indexed by topic

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our customer knowledge/research is in many places and hard to search.
 
L2 Most of our recent customer knowledge/research is in one place but few salespeople access it.
 
L3 We capture most of our current customer knowledge/insight in an easily accessed “library” accessible to a few salespeople.
 
L4 We capture all current customer knowledge/insight in a manual library that is formally indexed and maintained, accessible to all sales personal.
 
L5 We capture all current customer knowledge/insight in an electronic library that is searchable by any relevant variable and accessible to all business personnel.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Space Planning


The extent to which you employ space management disciplines in each of your key customers and to what degree you are used as a source of planning recommendations.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not do any space management with our key customers.
 
L2 We do some space management with some of our customers based on our own knowledge and experience of the category along with as much sales data as we can source. We are not used as a source for recommendations on ranging or shelf layout.
 
L3 We have people trained in space management doing work for some of our key customers, we employ space management software but are only used by a few our key customers as a source recommendations on ranging and shelf layout.
 
L4 We have people dedicated to space management for some of our key customers and employ space management software – we are used by some of our key customers as the key source on ranging and shelf layout.
 
L5 We have a team of people dedicated to space management for our key customers and employ space management software – we are the internal resource for most of our customers in building the category space plan.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
PROCESS: SUMMARY

Planning
Account planning
Resource allocation
Validation of robust customer strategies
Customer situation analysis
Category management process
Strategic management of pricing
Sales forecasting process

Execution
Promotion planning - Financial investment
Promotion planning - Internal controls
Promotion planning - Tailoring
Promotion planning - Reviews
Innovation pipeline
Promotion and NPD forecasting
Joint implementation planning
Tailored customer marketing activity
Brand POP orientation

Enablers
Customer performance reporting
Market performance monitoring tools
Customer knowledge library
Space planning
 
 
 
LEARNINGS: PROCESS
 
 
 
Sources of Advantage
   
 
 
 
Improvement Opportunities
   
 
 
 
MEASURES: KPI's
 
 
 
* Customer Scorecard


The extent to which your customer plans include a broad range of specific business targets developed in collaboration with your key customers

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not include financial targets in our customer plans.
 
L2 Our customer plans have some internal targets but these are not well communicated and are often inconsistent across sales, marketing and operations.
 
L3 Our customer plans have targets developed internally that are communicated and consistent across the business.
 
L4 Our customer plans have specific targets both financial and strategic based on feedback from the customer that then fed through into the customer, marketing and Supply chain plans.
 
L5 The business plan sets a broad range of multi-functional customer targets both financial and strategic based on collaboration with the customer that then fed through into the customer, marketing and Supply chain plans.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Specific P&L Statements


The extent to which your business understands the true cost to serve and value created of each of your customers and continually monitors this to improve efficiency

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not understand the true cost to serve our customers.
 
L2 We have some understanding of the true cost to serve our customers but are not using it yet.
 
L3 We have some understanding of the true cost to serve some of our key customers and we sometimes implement and monitor strategies to improve efficiency.
 
L4 We have a robust customer P&L for measuring the true cost to serve some of our key customers and we sometimes implement and monitor strategies to improve efficiency.
 
L5 We have a robust customer P&L for measuring the true cost to serve all of our key customers and we continually implement and monitor strategies to improve efficiency.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* NPD Performance Scorecard


NDP Performance is measured against the balanced scorecard of Lead KPI’s and Lag (measuring history e.g. Financial Performance, Brand Health and speed) KPI’s at both the progam (our NDP performance in total) and the individual initiative level

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our NDP tough performance scorecards are inconsistent or non-existent.
 
L2 Our NDP performance is reviewed against clearly defined lag KPI’s and monitoring encompasses only initiative performance.
 
L3 Our NDP performance is reviewed against clearly defined lead and lag KPI’s and monitoring encompasses only initiative performance.
 
L4 Our NDP performance is reviewed against clearly defined lag KPI’s and monitoring encompasses both program and initiative performance.
 
L5 Our NDP performance is reviewed against clearly defined lead and lag KPI’s and monitoring encompasses both program and initiative performance.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* NPD Performance Monitoring


NDP Performance monitoring is embedded through a score card which measures all key financial metrics, speed of distribution, rate of sale and all the executional and operational measures and this is reviewed regularly cross-functionally

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our NDP performance monitoring is inconsistent and not broadly defined.
 
L2 Our NDP performance KPI’s are somewhat defined and these are predominantly focused on sales and financial performance.
 
L3 Our NDP performance KPI’s are mostly defined from a financial perspective and from a detailed execution point of view. These are occasionally reviewed across the business.
 
L4 Our NDP performance KPI’s are clearly defined both from a financial perspective and from a detailed execution point of view. These are most often reviewed cross-functionally in the business.
 
L5 Our NDP performance KPI’s are clearly defined both from a financial perspective and from a detailed execution point of view. These are formally consistently, and frequently reviewed cross-functionally.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* New Product Tracking


The extent to which you track the progress of your distribution and sell-through of new product launches

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We tend not to track or measure the distribution nor sell-through of new product launches.
 
L2 We usually only measure progress of sell-through when customers complain about the performance of the product.
 
L3 We sometimes track/measure progress of distribution and sell-through of new product introductions e.g. when we are not hitting our budgets, when we are asked to report etc.
 
L4 We track/measure progress of distribution and sell-through of most new product introductions on a monthly basis for the first three months of launch (at least) usually on going.
 
L5 We track/measure progress of distribution (ex factory sales/shipments) and sell-through (scan sales) of all new product introductions on a weekly basis for the first three months of launch, then consistently ongoing.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Oriented Measurement


The extent to which your regular reporting tools and data analysis is able to reflect your key customers viewpoint of performance

For example you track category performance, total category profit, Customer GMROI, stock turns and margin performance as well as your own.

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not receive regular reporting on customer performance issues.
 
L2 We occasionally run analyses of customers’ performance but are not confident in the data accuracy and do not use in a dialogue with our customers.
 
L3 We regularly run analyses of customers’ performance that we believe are an accurate reflection of their performance but do not use in a dialogue with our customers.
 
L4 We have regular and accurate reports in place that track our customers’ performance that we use in our regular dialogue with them.
 
L5 We have comprehensive regular and accurate reports in place that we use to anticipate their performance concerns and initiate remedial actions.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
MEASURES: Management
 
 
 
* Business Management – Contingency Planning


The extent to which you have contingency plans pre-prepared collaboratively by business function (sales, operations, procurement etc) incorporating internal and external stakeholders (Marketing/Agencies and materials suppliers etc) should you strike difficulties in reaching or servicing your NDP or business targets

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not prepare backup strategies to assist in managing the meeting of our overall NDP targets.
 
L2 We have contingency plans pre-prepared by the Initiative Champion for each relevant business function incorporating internal and external stakeholders should we strike difficulties in reaching or servicing our NDP targets or over-performance.
 
L3 We have contingency plans pre-prepared collaboratively for each relevant business function incorporating internal stakeholders only should we strike difficulties in reaching or servicing our NDP targets or over-performance.
 
L4 We have contingency plans pre-prepared by the Initiative Champion for each relevant business function incorporating internal and external stakeholders only should we strike difficulties in reaching or servicing our NDP targets or over-performance.
 
L5 We have contingency plans pre-prepared collaboratively for each relevant business function incorporating internal and external stakeholders should we strike difficulties in reaching or servicing our NDP targets or over-performance.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Budget Management


The extent to which each Customer’s budget is controlled in line with agreed Sales and Marketing plans and forecasts and the extent to which it is administered flexibly to manage both long and short term brand value

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not control our budgets well in the short or long term.
 
L2 We sometimes control our Customer budgets in line with the latest agreed forecast and administer them with enough flexibility to ensure the delivery of maximum value in the short term only.
 
L3 We always control our Customer budgets in line with the latest agreed forecast and administer them with enough flexibility to ensure the delivery of maximum value in the short term only.
 
L4 We sometimes control our Customer budgets in line with the latest agreed forecast and administer them with enough flexibility to ensure the delivery of maximum value in the long and short term.
 
L5 We always control our Customer budgets in line with the latest agreed forecast and administer them with enough flexibility to ensure the delivery of maximum value in the long and short term.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Business Performance Management


To the extent which the customers holistic performance is formally and consistently measured and communicated across the organisation

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our NDP performance monitoring is inconsistent and not broadly defined.
 
L2 Our NDP performance KPI’s are somewhat defined and these are predominantly focused on sales and financial performance.
 
L3 Our NDP performance KPI’s are mostly defined both from a financial perspective and from a detailed execution point of view. These are occasionally reviewed across the business.
 
L4 We formally & most times conduct customer business performance reviews which are focused on evaluating key P&L performance KPI’s, market share along with tracking execution vs KPI’s on key activity.
 
L5 We formally & always conduct customer business performance reviews which are focused on evaluating key P&L performance KPI’s, market share along with tracking execution vs KPI’s on key initiatives & activity.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Customer Planning Review


The extent to which your customer plans are regularly reviewed and updated

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our customer plans are non-existing.
 
L2 Our customer plans are occasionally reviewed but this is ad-hoc and differs by account manager.
 
L3 Our customer plans are reviewed and updated as part of an informal process once or twice a year.
 
L4 Our customer plans are reviewed by all account managers (at least quarterly) as part of a formal process.
 
L5 Our customer plans are reviewed (at least quarterly) by all account Managers and the Sales Director as part of a formal process.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Initiative Execution Effectiveness


The extent to which the execution and implementation of Customer Plans and initiatives are measured

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We rarely, if ever, stop to review the effectiveness of customer initiatives.
 
L2 Most major customer initiatives are sometimes reviewed but this is largely anecdotal without any formal meetings or metrics.
 
L3 Most major customer initiatives are regularly rated and reviewed against a score card system which includes some metrics but the learnings are not applied consistently going forward.
 
L4 Customer initiatives are regularly rated and reviewed against a post evaluation scorecard – this forms the basis of future decisions around activity, resource and management.
 
L5 Customer initiatives are generally screened via a pre-evaluation process that includes some scorecard metrics developed for the type of activity. Once completed the initiatives are rated and reviewed against a post evaluation scorecard. Key learnings go into the evaluation process that forms the basis of future decisions around activity, resource and management.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* ROI Reviews


The degree to which you review investment on initiatives across financial metrics and involve your key customers in this process

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not prepare specific financial analysis on initiatives, we focus on top line sales figures and overall margin delivery.
 
L2 The financial impact of initiatives is evaluated pre-launch using broad measures (e.g. minimum volume and margin thresholds) but tracking is somewhat ad-hoc.
 
L3 The financial impact of initiatives is evaluated before and after launch using a broader set of measures including pay back and ROI analysis and we run an internal review at a suitable point post launch.
 
L4 The financial impact of initiatives are evaluated before and after launch using broader sets of measures including payback and ROI analysis and we run a formal review with our customers at a suitable point post launch.
 
L5 The financial impact of initiatives are evaluated before and after launch using broad and detailed financial analysis, supported by accounting expertise and this is shared with our customers for joint learning before and after the initiative.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
MEASURES SUMMARY

KPIs
Customer scorecard
Customer specific P&L statements
NPD performance scorecard
New product tracking
Customer oriented measurement

Management
Business management - Contingency planning
Budget management
Customer planning review
Initiative execution effectiveness
ROI reviews
 
 
 
LEARNINGS: MEASURES
 
 
 
Sources of Advantage
   
 
 
 
Improvement Opportunities
   
 
 
 
PEOPLE: Organisation
 
 
 
* Position Descriptions, Responsibilities & Authority Level


Position Descriptions for each role within Sales exist that define the levels of the specific outcomes the role is accountable for, the specific authority levels (i.e. which role the position has in which decisions, e.g. a recommender or decider and to what $ value) and include the standard tasks the role will be expected to perform

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We do not have Position Descriptions for every role in Sales
 
L2 Position Descriptions exist for every role and contain specific outcome responsibilities and authority levels but no standard tasks
 
L3 Position Descriptions exist for every role and contain specific authority levels as well as specific standard tasks
 
L4 Position Descriptions exist for every role and contain specific outcome responsibilities as well as specific standard tasks
 
L5 Position Descriptions exist for every role and contain specific outcome responsibilities and authority levels as well as specific standard tasks
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Performance – KPI Accountability

To the extent that individuals within the commercial team have absolute clarity in what they are accountable for and they take ownership for the deliverables

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Individuals within the team are not clear on their accountability and what is required to achieve them either individually or collaboratively. Roles seem unclear in its outputs.
 
L2 Individuals within the team are loosely accountable and are broadly clear about their KPI’s in detail and what is required to achieve them either individually or collaboratively. No real clear expectations placed on some roles.
 
L3 Some individuals within the team are somewhat accountable and are broadly clear about their KPI’s in detail and what is required to achieve them either individually or collaboratively. There are some clear direct implications that may occur should KPI’s not be delivered.
 
L4 Some individuals within the team are fully accountable and are very clear about their KPI’s in detail and what is required to achieve them either individually or collaboratively. There are some clear direct implications that may occur should KPI’s not be delivered.
 
L5 All individuals within the team are fully accountable and are very clear about their KPI’s in detail and what is required to achieve them either individually or collaboratively. There are clear direct implications that may occur should KPI’s not be delivered.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Performance Link to Rewards

The extent to which we reward our people for both individual and team performance

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our rewards system is not really linked to performance
 
L2 Our people rewards system unclearly and/or subjectively links an individual’s reward to EITHER their individual performance, their team’s performance or both
 
L3 Our people rewards system clearly and objectively links an individual’s reward to ONLY their team’s performance but not to individual performance
 
L4 Our people rewards system clearly and objectively links an individual’s reward to ONLY their individual performance but not to team performance
 
L5 Our people rewards system clearly and objectively links an individual’s reward to both individual and team performance
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Succession Planning

The extent to which succession plans exist in Sales as part of a company-wide Succession strategy. Demonstrated capability in Customer Management is a significant factor in succession planning for any Sales or Marketing that reports to a functional leader (e.g. Sales Director)

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 The business does not have succession plans in Sales and demonstrated capability in Customer Management varies in significance as a factor for senior Sales roles.
 
L2 The Marketing succession plan is part of a marketing-only initiative and demonstrated capability in Customer Management is a significant factor in Sales Leadership roles.
 
L3 The Sales succession plan is part of a company-wide discipline and demonstrated capability in Customer Management is a significant factor in Sales Leadership roles.
 
L4 The Sales succession plan is part of a sales-only initiative and demonstrated capability in Customer Management is a significant factor in internal promotion to Sales or Marketing Leadership roles.
 
L5 The Sales succession plan is part of a company-wide discipline and demonstrated capability in Customer Management is a significant factor in internal promotion to Sales or Marketing Leadership roles.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Objective Skill Audits

The extent to which you have Annual skill audits that include objective assessment techniques (e.g. reviews of actual work examples, interviews by specialists) and the extent to which specific levels are expected for an individual’s current role and the next role up the hierarchy

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 We subjectively assess skills on a needs basis from time to time.
 
L2 We complete annual subjective (Direct/Line Manager in discussion with employee) skill audits and feedback to individuals for their current level of skill versus the desired level for both their current role only.
 
L3 We complete annual subjective (Direct/Line Manager in discussion with employee) skill audits and feedback to individuals for their current level of skill versus the desired level for both their current role and the next role up.
 
L4 We complete annual objective skill audits and feedback to individuals for their current level of skill versus the desired level for their current role only.
 
L5 We complete annual objective skill audits and feedback to individuals for their current level of skill versus the desired level for both their current role and the next role up.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
* Cross-Functional Working

The extent to which your functions work together in executing customer plans and responding to ad-hoc customer issues (issues that arise outside of plan)

Please choose the response that most closely fits your assessment of the current status.

KEY: L1 Not undertaken, L2 Basic Activity, L3 Developed, L4 Advanced, L5 Best Practice
 
L1 Our business functions normally operate in silos with very little interaction and quite often cross-functional blame emerges.
 
L2 Our business functions sometimes work together but largely in response to a need rather than proactively.
 
L3 Our business functions work together on specific projects where there is a project manager to bring the team together.
 
L4 Our business functions work for the most part in a collaborative fashion toward achieving customer plans but we still have some trouble in collaborative responses to ad-hoc issues.
 
L5 Our business functions work consistently in a collaborative fashion toward achieving customer plans and responding to ad-hoc issues.
 
 
Please rate the potential impact each practice could have on your results if you were at L5 (Best Practice) for the previous question.

KEY: L1 Minimal Impact, L2 Noticeable Impact, L3 Competitive Edge L4 Step Change, L5 Game Change
L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
* Potential impact
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
 
 
PEOPLE SUMMARY

Organisation
Position descriptions, responsibilities & authority levels
Performance - KPI accountability
Performance link to rewards
Succession planning
Objective skill audits
Cross functional working
 
 
 
LEARNINGS: People
 
 
 
Sources of Advantage
   
 
 
 
Improvement Opportunities