Consumer Insights • August 22, 2023 • 7 min read
← Back to studies
Full-service restaurants demonstrate near-universal tipping alignment, whereas non-traditional service channels show substantially higher drop-offs in customer participation.
GET IT NOWTransactional recency confirms that sit-down dining generates the highest volume of tipped events, followed closely by food delivery apps and salon or barbershop visits.
GET IT NOWWhen assessing personal generosity, most consumers view themselves as moderate to heavy tippers, demonstrating that personal norms around gratuity remain positive across demographics.
GET IT NOWFrequency of tipping heavily favors table-service dining over quick-service establishments, underscoring that customers associate gratuity with extended face-to-face attention.
GET IT NOWStandard tip rates continue to anchor around 15%–20% for table service, but consumers report significantly lower percentage thresholds when presented with digital point-of-sale prompts at quick-serve counters.
GET IT NOWSelf-checkout screens and drive-thru windows face the steepest consumer resistance, establishing clear limits on where Americans feel gratuity is unwarranted.
GET IT NOW48% of respondents say tipping promotes better service and shows appreciation, while 22% argue it unfairly shifts compensation burdens away from employers.
GET IT NOWSource data for General Sentiment chart is not provided.
While 35% maintained pre-pandemic habits and 32% sustained elevated tipping levels, 24% retreated back to prior norms after initial pandemic shifts.
GET IT NOWSource data for Post-COVID Habits chart is not provided.
Americans maintain strong tipping expectations in full-service dining environments, while quick-serve, takeout, and counter settings show wide variability.
GET IT NOWSource data for Channel Expectations chart is not provided.
13% of consumers report feeling uncomfortable or awkward at checkout terminals, and 10% explicitly state tipping culture has gotten out of hand.
GET IT NOWSource data for Checkout Resistance chart is not provided.
Service Appreciation
48%
say tipping promotes better service
COVID Baseline Shift
32%
tipping increased and stayed higher
System Fairness Issue
22%
say tipping is not a fair reward model
Tipping remains deeply embedded in U.S. consumer culture, but attitudes are increasingly mixed. While many still see tipping as a way to reward service and show appreciation, others increasingly feel the system has become confusing or excessive. Full-service restaurants maintain the strongest tipping expectations, while takeout and self-service environments show more variation and uncertainty.
Key takeaways from our national study include:
48% say tipping promotes better service and shows appreciation: Gratuity continues to hold a strong position as an emotional instrument for signaling gratitude.
22% say tipping is not a fair system to reward employees: Over one-fifth feel the mechanism unfairly shifts compensation burdens onto customers.
13% feel tipping is often uncomfortable or awkward: Social friction at checkout terminals creates significant consumer unease during everyday purchases.
10% believe tipping culture has gotten out of hand: A notable segment explicitly identifies "tipflation" and expanding gratuity prompts as excessive.
32% say their tipping increased and stayed higher post-COVID: Pandemic-era generosity established an elevated baseline for nearly a third of households.
Self-checkout and drive-thrus face steep resistance: Automated kiosks and basic takeout orders register the highest levels of consumer tipping fatigue.
The online survey was conducted on August 22, 2023 by the QuestionPro Market Research Services Team. A total of 2,022 respondents participated in the survey. Respondents were selected from geographically representative double opt-in panels and all responses were reviewed for quality using standard verification processes. Margin of error is ±2.2% at a 95% confidence level.
Americans have mixed views about tipping. In this study, 48% said tipping is a good way to encourage better service and show appreciation, while 22% said it is not a fair system for rewarding employees.
Some consumers believe tipping expectations have become excessive. Ten percent of respondents said tipping culture has gotten out of hand, while 13% said tipping often feels uncomfortable or awkward.
Eight percent of respondents said they would prefer automatic service charges instead of traditional tipping. This suggests that a smaller but notable group of consumers favors a more predictable payment model.
The pandemic had a lasting effect on tipping for many consumers. Thirty-two percent said their tipping increased during COVID-19 and remained higher, while 24% said it increased temporarily before returning to previous levels.
Thirty-five percent of respondents said their tipping behavior had not changed since COVID-19. Another 10% said their tipping had decreased since the pandemic.
Tipping expectations are strongest in full-service restaurants and other settings where consumers receive direct personal service. Tipping behavior is more inconsistent in takeout, counter-service, and self-service environments.
Consumers often associate tipping with direct service, personal attention, and time spent by an employee. In takeout and self-service settings, the amount of service provided may be less clear, which can create uncertainty about whether a tip is expected.
Tip amounts can vary based on the type of service, quality of service, social expectations, the consumer’s budget, and whether the experience takes place in a full-service, takeout, or self-service environment.
The QuestionPro Market Research Services Team conducted the online survey on August 22, 2023. A total of 2,022 U.S. respondents participated, and the study had a margin of error of ±2.2% at a 95% confidence level.