Consumer & Social Insights • September 2026 • 8 min read
← Back to studies
Over 53% of surveyed consumers report feeling financially stretched heading into the season, leading 32.4% to plan spending cuts while another 21.5% intend to hold their budgets steady despite feeling the squeeze.
GET IT NOWA dominant 40.2% of consumers pinpoint persistent everyday expenses—such as groceries, housing, gas, and utilities—as the main reason for keeping holiday spending low, dwarfing income changes and debt servicing.
GET IT NOWWhile 60.7% of households plan to pay for gifts using ongoing cash flow or saved funds, 26.5% intend to finance their purchases primarily through credit card debt carried over time (13.0%) or Buy Now, Pay Later plans (13.5%).
GET IT NOWOnly 28.6% of shoppers believe store sale tags represent genuine savings. In contrast, 38.3% suspect base prices are artificially raised before sales, and 24.3% only trust discounts verified over time.
GET IT NOWWhen seeking maximum value, 33.6% of consumers look to major online retailers like Amazon, followed closely by big-box stores (27.1%) and off-price department stores (17.2%).
GET IT NOWOnly 23.9% of respondents plan to purchase non-family gifts as usual. The remaining 76.1% plan to keep gifts small (38.1%), eliminate them entirely (24.1%), or substitute physical items with baked goods and cards (13.9%).
GET IT NOWTo stretch funds without compromising quality, 36.6% of consumers choose to purchase one meaningful gift per recipient, while 28.3% select high-quality store brand alternatives.
GET IT NOWA striking 51.5% of adults report taking on credit card debt or feeling severe financial anxiety due to holiday expenses in past years, with 23.4% experiencing this strain almost every year.
GET IT NOWWhen budget cuts become unavoidable, consumers reduce spending on adult relatives and friends (25.7%) and lighting decorations (24.4%) long before cutting core family items.
GET IT NOWGifts for children and immediate family (41.8%) and traditional holiday meals (29.3%) serve as the primary non-negotiables that parents refuse to sacrifice regardless of economic pressure.
GET IT NOWFinancially Stretched
53.9%
feel strain heading into holidays
Everyday Cost Driver
40.2%
cite sticky living costs as main constraint
Discount Skepticism
62.6%
distrust promotional sale prices
The 2026 holiday shopping season reveals a striking consumer paradox: while persistent everyday living costs leave consumers feeling overwhelmed, holiday spending remains emotionally sacred. Rather than abandoning celebrations, Americans are executing a tactical overhaul of their shopping behaviors—pruning non-family gift lists, spreading purchases into early autumn, and focusing on high-impact gifts and meals.
Key takeaways from our national study include:
53.9% feel financially stretched: Budget strain is driving 32.4% of consumers to explicitly plan holiday spending cuts.
40.2% cite sticky everyday costs as primary constraint: Non-discretionary inflation (groceries, housing, utilities) outpaces debt and income changes.
62.6% distrust promotional sale prices: Consumers suspect artificial base price hikes or demand price-tracking verification.
76.1% scale back non-family gifts: Shoppers draw clear boundaries around coworkers, neighbors, and acquaintances.
36.6% adopt a "one meaningful gift" strategy: Families replace massive gift piles with single, high-impact items per person.
Children's gifts (41.8%) and festive meals (29.3%) are non-negotiable: Core family rituals remain protected despite severe financial pressure.
This study was conducted by the QuestionPro Market Research Services team among n=1,000 U.S. adults (ages 18+). Data was collected via an online survey using non-probability sampling from double opt-in panels. The sample reflects diverse demographic distributions across age, state residence, and income levels, aligned with U.S. census benchmarks where applicable. All respondents were verified, and responses were securely stored. Margin of error is approximately ±3.1% at a 95% confidence level.
According to the QuestionPro 2026 Holiday Spending Study, 53.9% of U.S. adults feel financially stretched heading into the holiday season. Specifically, 32.4% plan to cut back their spending, while another 21.5% feel stretched but intend to keep their budgets steady regardless.
Sticky everyday living costs—such as groceries, housing, gas, and utilities—are the leading cause of budget tightening, cited by 40.2% of consumers. This far outpaces recent changes in household income (17.6%) or managing credit card debt (17.1%).
No. Nearly two-thirds of Americans (62.6%) express skepticism toward holiday sale prices. Specifically, 38.3% believe stores raise base prices before placing items on sale, and 24.3% only trust a discount if they have tracked the item's price history over time.
Over half of Americans (51.5%) have taken on credit card debt or experienced severe financial anxiety due to holiday spending. Nearly one-quarter (23.4%) report that holiday financial strain occurs almost every year.
76.1% of consumers are reducing or eliminating gifts for non-immediate family members. This includes 38.1% keeping non-family gifts very small and inexpensive, 24.1% skipping non-family gifts completely, and 13.9% replacing bought gifts with baked goods or favors.
Gifts for children and immediate family members (41.8%) and special holiday meals (29.3%) serve as top non-negotiable budget items. When cuts are required, families scale back adult gifts (25.7%) and holiday lighting decorations (24.4%) first.
Holiday shopping is starting earlier than ever: 79.5% of consumers plan to complete most of their shopping before December. In fact, 52.5% plan to finish before Cyber Week even begins, utilizing early autumn sales to spread out household costs.
Yes. 72.2% of respondents state that decorating their home for fall, Halloween, or winter holidays helps lift their family's spirits during financially difficult periods, with 36.1% saying it brings substantial emotional joy.